When it comes to left-overs there are three types of people, the “Don’t You Dare Throw That Away” type, the “Count Me Out” group, and my favorite type, the “Don’t You Dare Throw That Away…I Will Keep it in My Fridge For a Week and Then Throw it Out!” people. I think we’ve all had the experience of looking into the refrigerator of someone who fits into the latter category.
I’ve never been a left-over girl, but candy is a definite exception. One of the best ways to get rid of left-over Halloween candy is by baking with it. Cookies, brownies, cakes, pies… think outside of the recipe card! Last year my boy and I decided to make a candy bar coffee cake after Halloween. It turned out great – coffee cake and chocolate, what’s not to love? I have already pilfered my son’s candy bag. Is that morally wrong? I do feel a little guilty. I’ve eaten the Snicker’s bars (my greatest weakness), but have hidden the Butterfinger’s for a recipe I’ll share next week.
Here are some of my favorites sweets I’ve baked with candy (pictured above)
- Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookies
- Toffee Chip Snickerdoodles
- GIANT Chocolate Toffee Cookies
- Willy Wonka’s Candy Bar Coffeecake
- Peanut Butter Cup S’mores Pie
- Butterfinger’s Cookies
- Snicker’s Cookies
- Snicker’s Pie
- Banana Malt Shop Cupcakes
- Whopper’s Ice Cream Pie
- Whopper Chocolate Cheesecake








Hey Katie – Love, love, love the blog! You were in the paper again on Saturday in the local section under Ladera – just a recap of the previous article. I may call you this weekend for some ideas. We’re having a Thanksgiving Potluck at work & I’m in charge of decorations. I don’t need too much and don’t want to spend a lot, so put your thinking cap on & I’ll call you for ideas.
Thanks –
Terry : )
Hi Katie,Terry told me about your blog yesterday and I absolutely love it. I worked with Terry at Annex I a few years ago. I loved to bake, wish I new about your blog sooner! I just polished off all the Halloween candy which of course Whoppers and Snickers are my favorites. I’m going to restock both, bake the Snicker cookies and try the Whopper Ice Cream Pie. Thank you for the wonderful ideas. Yum!
Hi Cathy!
Thanks for checking out the blog! I’m so glad you and Terry have stayed friends. They eliminated her position for our dept. We miss her terribly! There is just no replacing Terry!